Games Like Crying Pony

Crying Pony

Crying Pony is a 2D side-scrolling horror game where the protagonist, Michael, is hunted by the lurking evil in his nightmares. As the nightmare's corruption seeps into reality and even pulls Michael's daughter into its grasp, will he be able to lead them both to escape from the nightmare?

★ MR. HOPP'S PLAYHOUSE 2 ★ TERROR AT OAKHEART ★ BURNHOUSE LANE ★ ZOOCHOSIS ★ VASILISA AND BABA YAGA ★ GHOST WATCHERS ★ I HAVE NO MOUTH, AND I MUST SCREAM ★ PENUMBRA OVERTURE ★ BLAMELESS ★ LITTLE NIGHTMARES II ★ IMSCARED ★ THE CAT LADY ★ WE ♥ IT 
2

Terror At Oakheart

81% 👍 OF 479
About This Game

The renowned slasher horror films of the 1980s and 1990s serve as a source of inspiration for Terror at Oakheart. The community of Oakheart has been terrorized by Teddy, a masked serial killer. As the body count rises, you discover there is more going on here than just a man in a mask.

3

Burnhouse Lane

94% 👍 OF 1.2K
About This Game

Burnhouse Lane tells a story of Angie Weather, a one foot in the grave agency nurse attempting to complete five impossible tasks in order to win her life back. Solve puzzles, make friends and enemies, run, hide and fight in this dark adventure that'll take you on a trip to another world and back...

Player reviews say you can…

  • …Complete Five Otherworldly Tasks
  • …Solve Item-Based Puzzles
  • …Choose Who to Trust
4

Zoochosis

61% 👍 OF 2.4K
About This Game

Zoochosis is a bodycam horror simulation game. You’re a zookeeper. Identify infected mutant animals, make a vaccine and cure them. Will you save all of them and survive?

Player reviews say you can…

  • …Diagnose Sick Animals
  • …Mix Animal Vaccines
  • …Clean Zoo Enclosures
5

Vasilisa and Baba Yaga

90% 👍 OF 970
About This Game

An adventure game based on the Russian folktale "Vasilisa the Beautiful". A scary story about the journey to the mistress of the forbidden forest for magical powers.

Player reviews say you can…

  • …Battle Forest Spirits
  • …Sneak Past Creatures
  • …Do Witch’s Chores
7

I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream

89% 👍 OF 4.1K
About This Game

The adventure plunges you into the tortured and hidden past of five humans. Delve into their darkest fears. Outwit the Master Computer AM in a game of psychological warfare. Disturbing, compelling. An adventure you won't easily forget !!

Player reviews say you can…

  • …Uncover Five Pasts
  • …Outwit a Master Computer
  • …Solve Point-and-Click Puzzles
8

Penumbra Overture

90% 👍 OF 4.2K
About This Game

Penumbra: Overture is a first person survival horror game, emphasizing on survival and problem solving instead of mindless violence and gore.

Player reviews say you can…

  • …Explore a Frozen Mine
  • …Manipulate Physical Objects
  • …Solve Environmental Puzzles
9

Blameless

84% 👍 OF 5.1K
About This Game

Blameless is a mysterious first-person adventure with primary focus on puzzle solving and short story. The player will appear in a role of an architect trying to investigate strange happenings, after discovering evidence of an act of violence.

Player reviews say you can…

  • …Escape an Unfinished House
  • …Repurpose Building Tools
  • …Investigate Violent Clues
REL Oct 13, 2016 FREE ON STEAM See This Game →
10

Little Nightmares II

93% 👍 OF 58K
About This Game

Little Nightmares II is the second game in a series that has thrilled and captivated millions of players worldwide since 2017. Now it’s your turn to try to survive this critically acclaimed entry in the most charming horror series ever made.

Player reviews say you can…

  • …call out to your partner, hear her answer, and hold hands as you move together through dangerous areas.
  • …enter televisions and travel through the Signal, moving deeper toward whatever is broadcasting it.
  • …wake up alone in a forest of burned-out televisions, dodge traps, and find a girl locked in a basement with only a music box.
11

IMSCARED

95% 👍 OF 4.0K
About This Game

"I need a Heart in order to open it"

Player reviews say you can…

  • …get messages from a folder the game creates on your desktop, then open and edit its .txt/.htm/.config files to solve puzzles.
  • …have the game open browser tabs and videos, create files, and fake blue-screen-like events as part of progression.
  • …lose the shift key mid-chase, forcing you to keep running while the game removes a basic control option.
12

The Cat Lady

94% 👍 OF 6.3K
About This Game

The Cat Lady follows Susan Ashworth, a lonely 40-year old on the verge of suicide. She has no family, no friends and no hope for a better future. One day she discovers that five strangers will come along and change everything...

Player reviews say you can…

  • …Confront Five Parasites
  • …Explore Susan’s Visions
  • …Solve Story Puzzles