We Love It's Guide to…
As a police investigator, match witnesses’ descriptions to randomly generated suspects and decide whom to send to the electric chair.
Released 18 Aug 2015
Read Witness Descriptions
Scan Suspect Lineups
Choose the Guilty Suspect
GUILTY! THEY ARE ALL GUILTY! FINGERED is a "whodunit" hyperrealisic police sim where you must finger the guilty and clean up this darn city using the descriptions of the local busy bodies. but everyone's perspective is different: one man's fat is another man's sexy! send him to the chair!!!
Developed by Edmund McMillen, James Id · Published by Edmund McMillen, James Id









Fingered casts you as a police investigator judging suspects in a series of murder cases. Each level presents a lineup of unusual characters and a witness’s account of the culprit.
Study the descriptions and compare them with the suspects’ visible traits, then choose who is guilty. The challenge is interpreting witnesses’ words and deciding which person best fits their account.
The game has 21 levels, randomly generated suspects, and a limited allowance for mistakes, making each accusation risky. A criminal database and achievements provide additional goals.
Reviews are mixed. Players who enjoy the game often mention its dark humor, strange randomly generated characters, and quick, simple deduction loop. Some also like the challenge of completing cases or achievements. A recurring complaint is that witness clues can feel vague or conflict with what players see, leaving them to guess and potentially restart; some reviewers also find the experience short or repetitive.
| Platforms | Windows |
|---|---|
| Achievements | 24 |
| Age ratings |
|
| Controller required | No |
| Website | Official website |